Live Alaska's ranked-choice count is today. The Senate, governor and House races, round by round. The rounds
Live
Analysis · Results · 4 min read

The incumbents who lost in 2026, and what they had in common

Six senators and 33 House members lost re-election in November, and no Democrat lost a seat to a Republican. Most of the House losses were narrow, and in most of the narrowest, the incumbent had raised more money.

In a wave year, the clearest measure of the wave is who it carried out. In 2026 that was six senators and 33 members of the House who ran for re-election in November and lost. All six senators were Republicans. Of the 33 House members, 30 were Republicans beaten by Democrats, and the other three lost in California's top-two system. No Democrat lost a seat to a Republican.

The losses add up. As of November 16, Republicans hold 172 House seats with six races still uncalled, down from the 220 they won in 2024. A drop that size would tie 1958 and 1974 for the fourth-largest loss by a president's party in a midterm since 1946, behind 2010, 1946 and 1994. In the Senate, Republicans go from 53 seats to 44.

The Senate: six Republicans out

SenatorBeaten byMargin
MississippiCindy Hyde-SmithScott Colom (D)0.8
AlaskaDan SullivanMary Peltola (D)4.0
South CarolinaDarline GrahamAnnie Andrews (D)4.5
OhioJon HustedSherrod Brown (D)4.9
KansasRoger MarshallAdam Hamilton (D)5.1
MaineSusan CollinsTroy Jackson (D)6.1

None of them lost by much more than six points, and Mississippi came down to 7,587 votes. Two had been appointed to the seat rather than elected to it: Jon Husted in 2025, when JD Vance became vice president, and Darline Graham this year, after the death of her brother, Senator Lindsey Graham. At the other end is Susan Collins, who had won five Senate elections in Maine.

Money didn't decide these races. Of the five with comparable filings, only Hyde-Smith raised more than the Democrat who beat her. One more senator lost before November: Bill Cassidy, in the Louisiana Republican primary, to Julia Letlow.

The House: 33 losses, most of them close

Fourteen of the 33 House incumbents lost by less than five points, 12 by five to ten, and seven by more than ten. The closest race of the year was one of them: in North Carolina's 3rd District, Raymond Smith Jr. leads Representative Greg Murphy by 258 votes, with an estimated 89% of the vote counted. It could still change.

The losses were concentrated:

  • North Carolina, 5: Greg Murphy (NC-03), Addison McDowell (NC-06), Richard Hudson (NC-09), Brad Knott (NC-13) and Tim Moore (NC-14), every one by 2.5 points or less, in the year Roy Cooper won the state's Senate race.
  • Pennsylvania, 4: Brian Fitzpatrick (PA-01), Ryan Mackenzie (PA-07), Rob Bresnahan (PA-08) and Scott Perry (PA-10).
  • California, 4: Mike Thompson (CA-04) and Jimmy Gomez (CA-34), both Democrats, lost to fellow Democrats. Kevin Kiley, listed in our results without a party label, lost CA-06 to Democrat Richard Pan, and David Valadao lost CA-22 by 35.6 points, the widest margin of any defeated incumbent. California redrew its House map in 2025, so all four were running in districts that had changed.
  • Ohio, 3: Mike Turner (OH-10), Max Miller (OH-07) and Mike Carey (OH-15).
  • Two each in Colorado, Iowa, Michigan, New Jersey, Virginia and Wisconsin, and one each in Arizona, Indiana, Missouri, New York and Texas.

More money didn't save them

You might expect incumbents to lose when they're outraised. Most of these weren't. Eighteen of the 33 House incumbents who lost had raised more than the candidate who beat them, 13 had raised less, and two had raised about the same.

The pattern is sharpest in the closest races. Of the 14 incumbents who lost by less than five points, 13 had raised more than their opponent, often far more. In NC-14, Lakesha Womack raised about $59,000 and beat Tim Moore, who raised $2.1 million. In NC-03, Raymond Smith Jr. raised about $367,000 to Greg Murphy's $2.9 million. The one exception was Lauren Boebert in CO-04, who raised $1.2 million and lost by 0.9 points to Eileen Laubacher, who raised $13.7 million.

The wider losses look different. In those, the Democrat more often raised as much as or more than the incumbent: Rebecca Bennett had $8.8 million to Thomas Kean Jr.'s $6.1 million in NJ-07, and Janelle Stelson $9.2 million to Scott Perry's $6.8 million in PA-10.

My read: the narrow losses to little-known, lightly funded challengers are what a wave looks like. Those voters weren't choosing between two campaigns so much as between two parties, and a few million dollars of incumbent money didn't change that. The question for 2028 is how many of these seats the new members can keep once they're the incumbents and the national mood is no longer doing the work for them.

How we measured this

Incumbents are candidates the Federal Election Commission lists as 2026 incumbents, matched to the results by last name and party, plus Darline Graham, who was appointed to her seat this year and isn't flagged as the incumbent in that data. Margins are from the latest count, and several races are still being counted, so the closest ones could change. Money is what each campaign committee raised in the 2025–2026 cycle, from FEC filings; outside spending is not included, and South Carolina is left out of the Senate money comparison because the filings there include Lindsey Graham's committee from before his death, which makes the comparison unclear. Governors aren't included: our sources don't flag which governor candidates were incumbents. Seat changes by midterm since 1946 are from the American Presidency Project at UC Santa Barbara. The full list is on our incumbents who lost page.

Sources

  1. Federal Election Commission: candidate and committee data
  2. The American Presidency Project: seats gained or lost by the president's party in midterm elections

Written and edited by Brian Davis. Research help from AI tools; every number checked against the linked data. See a mistake? Tell us. Last updated .

Was this useful?

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first.

See an error on this page? Let us know · Missing something? Suggest it

Accessibility options

These settings are saved in this browser only.

Text size
Display
Reading

Every chart also has a data table. See our accessibility statement.

Ad changes apply from the next page you open.