For most of the last decade, American voters have picked one party and stuck with it all the way down the ballot. In 2026, most still did. But in a few places, enough voters split their tickets to elect a senator from one party and a governor from the other, and a surprising number of states elected someone from the party that lost them badly in 2024.
Two states split their top races
Twenty-six states held both a Senate and a governor's race this year with both results called. In 24 of them, the same party won both. Two split:
- New Hampshire elected Democrat Chris Pappas to the Senate by 13.7 points and re-elected Republican Gov. Kelly Ayotte by 4.4. That's a gap of about 18 points between the two races on the same ballot.
- South Carolina elected Democrat Annie Andrews to the Senate by 4.5 points, defeating Sen. Darline Graham, who was appointed to the seat after her brother, Sen. Lindsey Graham, died this year, while electing Republican Alan Wilson governor by the same 4.5-point margin. That's a 9-point gap, and a remarkable result in a state Donald Trump carried easily in 2024.
Two out of 26 isn't many. But in a period when splits like this almost disappeared, it's two more than many recent elections produced. In 2016, every Senate race went the same way as the state's presidential vote; in 2020, only Maine split.
Winning where your party lost
A broader kind of crossover shows up when you compare 2026 with 2024. Twenty-three Senate and governor's races this year were won by the party that lost that state in the 2024 presidential race: 21 by Democrats, 2 by Republicans.
Some of the Democratic wins came in states Trump carried comfortably:
- Mississippi: Scott Colom won the Senate race in a state Trump won by almost 23 points.
- Alaska: Democrats Mary Peltola (Senate) and Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins (governor) won in a state Trump carried by 13.
- Ohio: Democrats Sherrod Brown (Senate) and Amy Acton (governor) won in a state Trump carried by 11.
Others came in the swing states that Trump narrowly won in 2024: Georgia, Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin.
The two Republican exceptions were in New England. Vermont re-elected Republican Gov. Phil Scott in a state Kamala Harris won by 31 points, and New Hampshire re-elected Ayotte in a state Harris won by about 3. Both are incumbents with their own brands, which is usually what it takes to win across party lines now.
The counties that split
Looking county by county, splits were rare but not random. Of the 510 counties that finished counting both a Senate and a governor's race, 37 voted for different parties in the two races.
They went both ways:
- 20 counties voted Republican for Senate and Democratic for governor. Half of them were in Iowa, where the Democratic candidate for governor ran well ahead of the party's Senate candidate. Buchanan County voted Republican for Senate by 11 points and Democratic for governor by 3.
- 17 counties voted Democratic for Senate and Republican for governor, mostly in South Carolina and New Hampshire, the two states that split. Carroll County, N.H., voted for Pappas by 6 points and for Ayotte by 13.
In Maine, Kennebec County was the closest kind of split: the Republican won the Senate race there by two-tenths of a point, while the Democrat won the governor's race by 10.
What it tells us
Three things stand out:
- Candidates can still matter, at the edges. The splits happened where one side had an unusually strong or well-known candidate, like a sitting governor with a moderate reputation, or a weak one. Darline Graham's loss in South Carolina, while her party held the governorship, is the clearest case.
- A wave lifts the whole ticket. Most of the "crossover" wins this year weren't really ticket-splitting: Democrats won both the Senate and governor's races in Georgia, Michigan, Ohio and Alaska. That's a party-wide swing, not voters choosing different parties for different offices.
- Iowa is worth watching. Ten counties there voted Republican for Senate and Democratic for governor, the biggest cluster of splits in the country. Democrats won both races there, but the governor's race by about 11 points and the Senate race by about 4. One likely reason: Rob Sand, the Democrat elected governor, had already won statewide twice as state auditor.
My read is that 2026 was mostly a wave, not a comeback for ticket-splitting. Most of the crossover wins came from one party winning everything. But New Hampshire and South Carolina show that a well-known candidate, or a weak one, can still move enough voters across party lines to matter, and that's worth watching in the 2028 Senate races.
How we measured this
A state "split" when different parties won its Senate and governor's races. Crossover winners are 2026 Senate and governor winners from the party that lost the state's 2024 presidential vote. County splits use only counties that have finished counting both races. Results come from civicAPI; 2024 presidential results come from FiveThirtyEight. Everything here is on our ticket-splitting page, which updates as counting finishes, and county results are on each state's page (for example, New Hampshire by county).
Sources
- Polling Desk ticket-splitting (civicAPI 2026 results; FiveThirtyEight 2024 presidential results)
- WRDW: Democrat Annie Andrews wins U.S. Senate election in South Carolina over Republican Darline Graham
- OPB (AP): Democrat Rob Sand wins election to be Iowa's next governor
Written and edited by Brian Davis. Research help from AI tools; every number checked against the linked data. See a mistake? Tell us. Last updated .
Was this useful?
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.
See an error on this page? Let us know · Missing something? Suggest it



